Stock Market Outlook 2023: Reasons for Optimism

The stock market in 2023 is shaping up to be a year full of opportunities and cautious optimism. While the memories of the bear market of 2022 still linger, there are several compelling reasons to believe that the stock market could have a surprisingly strong performance, particularly in the first half of the year. This outlook is supported by historical trends, economic indicators, and sector-specific insights that suggest value stocks and Asia ex-Japan markets could be key areas of focus for investors. However, the risk of recession may loom in the second half of the year, necessitating a balanced approach to investment strategies.

A Strong First Half: Historical Trends and Economic Indicators

One of the primary reasons for optimism in 2023 is rooted in historical analysis, particularly the patterns observed in the S&P 500 during presidential cycles. According to Andrew Slimmon, Head of the Applied Equity Advisors Team at Morgan Stanley Investment Management, the first quarter of the third year of a presidential cycle has consistently been the strongest since 1950. This trend holds true even in the current cycle, where the S&P 500 has shown positive momentum. Historically, in the 12 months following a midterm election year, the S&P 500 has averaged a 33% gain, with every instance resulting in an increase. This bodes well for the current year, as 2022 was a midterm election year.

Economic indicators further support the case for a strong start to the year. Despite widespread concerns about a potential downturn, key metrics such as GDP growth and employment figures indicate that the U.S. economy remains resilient. The outperformance of cyclical stocks—particularly in sectors like financials, industrials, and materials—suggests that the market is not yet bracing for a significant economic slowdown. These sectors typically decline before the broader economy falters, yet they have continued to perform well, signaling confidence in the near-term economic outlook.

Inflation, a major concern throughout 2022, has shown signs of easing, further bolstering the case for a strong first quarter. As inflationary pressures recede, the potential for corporate earnings to collapse appears less likely. Instead, earnings may experience a gradual decline throughout the year, frustrating those who are overly bearish on the market.

Opportunities in Value Sectors

The shift towards value stocks, which began in the fourth quarter of 2022, presents another reason for optimism in 2023. Historically, value stocks have tended to outperform during periods of economic uncertainty or when growth stocks, particularly in the technology sector, have become overvalued. This pattern is reminiscent of the post-dotcom bubble period in the early 2000s, when investors who continued to chase technology stocks missed out on the strong performance of value sectors such as industrials, financials, and materials.

In 2023, there is a striking similarity to the behavior observed during the dotcom bubble. Despite the strong performance of value stocks, many investors remain fixated on the high-growth technology stocks that dominated the previous bull market. This could be a costly mistake, as the regulatory environment and slowing growth rates are likely to weigh on mega-cap tech stocks. The U.S. government’s increased scrutiny of these companies, combined with their already high valuations, suggests that their dominance in the S&P 500 may be challenged in the coming years.

The S&P 500’s concentration in a few large technology stocks is a potential risk that investors should not overlook. At their peak in 2022, the five largest tech stocks accounted for 25% of the index, a level of concentration similar to that seen during the dotcom bubble. Historically, such high concentrations have been followed by significant declines, as was the case when the top tech stocks of 2000 saw their market cap shrink from over 20% of the S&P 500 to just 5% five years later. While the current valuations are not as extreme, the parallels suggest that investors should be cautious about overexposure to these stocks.

Instead, sectors like energy, industrials, materials, and financials offer compelling opportunities for value-oriented investors. These sectors have already begun to outperform, and their valuations remain attractive relative to the broader market. By focusing on these areas, investors may be able to capitalize on the shift from growth to value, potentially leading to significant gains in 2023.

Watch Asia Ex-Japan, Especially China

Beyond the U.S., emerging markets—particularly Asia ex-Japan—present intriguing opportunities for investors in 2023. The U.S. dollar, which peaked in September 2022, has since weakened, leading to the outperformance of non-U.S. markets. Among these, Asia ex-Japan has been a standout, particularly since the end of October 2022.

China, in particular, warrants close attention. Unlike most major central banks, the People’s Bank of China has not engaged in aggressive tightening of monetary policy. Additionally, the Chinese government’s recent shift away from its strict zero-COVID policy is expected to boost economic activity in the country. These factors, combined with the global growth recovery, make China an attractive destination for investment. While institutional investors have already started moving money back into China, retail investors have largely remained on the sidelines. This hesitancy may represent an opportunity for those willing to take on some risk.

The broader Asia ex-Japan region also benefits from favorable macroeconomic conditions, including improved trade dynamics and relatively low inflation compared to the U.S. and Europe. As global growth accelerates and U.S. bond market yields become less attractive, capital flows into these emerging markets are likely to increase, driving further outperformance.

Beware of Rear-View Mirror Investing

One of the most significant risks facing investors in 2023 is the tendency to base decisions on the experiences of the past, particularly the bear market of 2022. This recency bias can lead to overly cautious behavior, causing investors to miss out on potential gains. As Slimmon notes, many investors are still looking in the rear-view mirror, focusing on the pains of the previous bear market rather than the opportunities that lie ahead.

This cautious mindset has been evident in the reluctance of many investors to fully participate in the market recovery. While some have dipped their toes back into the market, there remains a widespread skepticism about the sustainability of the current rally. However, as prices continue to rise, there is a risk that these same investors will become more optimistic, but only after much of the upside has already been realized.

The key to navigating the 2023 stock market lies in balancing optimism with caution. While there are clear opportunities, particularly in value sectors and emerging markets, the risk of a recession in the second half of the year cannot be ignored. Investors should remain vigilant, avoiding the pitfalls of rear-view mirror investing, and instead focus on the forward-looking indicators that suggest where the market is headed.

Conclusion

The stock market in 2023 is poised for a potentially strong performance, particularly in the first half of the year. Historical trends, resilient economic indicators, and sector-specific opportunities all point to a market that may defy the widespread pessimism left over from 2022. However, investors must remain aware of the risks that could emerge in the second half of the year, particularly the possibility of a recession.

By focusing on value sectors, such as energy, industrials, materials, and financials, and keeping an eye on emerging markets like Asia ex-Japan, investors can position themselves to take advantage of the opportunities that 2023 has to offer. At the same time, it is crucial to avoid the trap of rear-view mirror investing, which can lead to missed opportunities and suboptimal returns. With a balanced approach, 2023 could be a year of significant gains for those who navigate the market with both optimism and caution.

Keep up-to-date with breaking news and updates on glamourtomorrow